Praxis Consulting - A Division of Allied Global Standards LLP
BRSR Core Assurance: Building Value Chain ESG Data You Can Defend
InsightsSustainability & ESG

BRSR Core Assurance: Building Value Chain ESG Data You Can Defend

Praxis Consulting Insights Team
2026-11-17

Executive Summary

BRSR Core assurance has phased in from the top 150 listed entities to the top 1,000, and value chain disclosures are now being introduced for the largest companies. This article sets out a practical roadmap for building assurable, supplier-level ESG data across Indian value chains.

<h2>Why Value Chain Data Is the Next Assurance Challenge</h2><p>The question in Indian boardrooms has shifted from <em>whether</em> to report on sustainability to <em>whether the numbers will withstand assurance scrutiny</em>. Most listed companies have spent the last two years stabilising their own-operations data under the Business Responsibility and Sustainability Report (BRSR) and its assured subset, BRSR Core. The next frontier lies beyond the factory gate: value chain data on suppliers and distributors, which few enterprises can yet evidence.</p><p>This article explains where BRSR Core stands, what SEBI requires for value chain disclosures, where the typical gaps lie, and how to build a defensible, assurance-ready capability.</p><h2>1. From Narrative to Financial-Grade: Where BRSR Stands</h2><p>SEBI introduced the BRSR in May 2021. Filing became mandatory for the top 1,000 listed companies by market capitalisation from FY 2022-23, replacing the earlier Business Responsibility Report. In July 2023, SEBI (circular SEBI/HO/CFD/CFD-SEC-2/P/CIR/2023/122) introduced BRSR Core, a focused set of key performance indicators intended to be comparable and verifiable, together with a phased assurance requirement:</p><ul><li><strong>FY 2023-24:</strong> top 150 listed entities</li><li><strong>FY 2024-25:</strong> top 250 listed entities</li><li><strong>FY 2025-26:</strong> top 500 listed entities</li><li><strong>FY 2026-27:</strong> top 1,000 listed entities</li></ul><p>Initially, assurance has been at the limited level, with a glide path toward reasonable assurance for the BRSR Core indicators over time. Companies should confirm the current schedule against the latest SEBI circulars, but the direction is clear: the evidentiary standard is rising every year.</p><p>BRSR Core is organised around nine attributes:</p><ul><li><strong>Green-house gas (GHG) footprint</strong></li><li><strong>Water footprint</strong></li><li><strong>Energy footprint</strong></li><li><strong>Embracing circularity</strong> (waste management)</li><li><strong>Enhancing employee wellbeing and safety</strong></li><li><strong>Enabling gender diversity in business</strong></li><li><strong>Enabling inclusive development</strong></li><li><strong>Fairness in engaging with customers and suppliers</strong></li><li><strong>Openness of business</strong></li></ul><p>Assurance providers are no longer reviewing a narrative. They test data lineage, sample source records, challenge estimation methods and evaluate internal controls over non-financial information. Globally this mirrors ISSA 5000, the IAASB&#39;s general standard for sustainability assurance (effective for periods beginning on or after 15 December 2026), and ISO 14064-3 for verification of greenhouse gas statements. In India, assurance engagements are generally performed under ISAE 3000 (Revised) or ICAI&#39;s equivalent, SAE 3000.</p><p>Key characteristics of the current environment include:</p><ul><li><strong>Rising assurance expectations:</strong> Leading companies are voluntarily preparing for reasonable assurance on selected KPIs ahead of the mandated glide path.</li><li><strong>Board accountability:</strong> Audit and Risk Committees are increasingly asked to oversee non-financial reporting controls.</li><li><strong>Investor scrutiny:</strong> Institutional investors and stewardship bodies compare BRSR data year on year and across peers, exposing inconsistencies.</li><li><strong>Regulatory convergence:</strong> BRSR is being mapped against GRI, IFRS S1 and S2 and the CSRD&#39;s ESRS, so a single, well-governed data foundation is far more efficient than parallel reporting streams.</li></ul><h2>2. What SEBI Requires on Value Chain Disclosures</h2><p>SEBI&#39;s framework now extends to the value chain. Under the BRSR Core framework and the related industry standards note issued in 2025, the top 250 listed entities are required to make value chain disclosures on selected BRSR Core indicators from FY 2025-26. The disclosures cover the upstream (suppliers) and downstream (distributors and customers) value chain, and the scope is defined by a threshold of 75% of purchases and sales by value. Assurance on these value chain disclosures is initially on a limited, comfort-level basis, rather than full assurance.</p><p>The effect is practical. A company must identify which suppliers and distributors make up three-quarters of its purchase and sales value, obtain data from them, and be able to explain how that data was collected, checked and consolidated. Even where assurance is not yet formal, the data becomes public and will be read by investors, lenders and customers.</p><h2>3. Why Buyers and Lenders Are Asking Anyway</h2><p>Regulation is only one driver. Indian exporters and suppliers to multinationals face requests tied to the EU CSRD, the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD), and the EU&#39;s CBAM. Banks are asking for financed or supplier emissions evidence, and global brands set Scope 3 reduction targets that cascade to Indian suppliers. Companies that cannot supply credible supplier-level data risk losing preferred-vendor status.</p><h2>4. Where the Gaps Typically Lie</h2><p>Across industries, readiness reviews tend to find the same weaknesses:</p><ul><li><strong>No clear supplier universe.</strong> Procurement systems rarely map suppliers to the 75% value threshold, and tier-two and tier-three visibility is minimal.</li><li><strong>Estimation without method.</strong> Scope 3 figures are often built from spend-based emission factors with no documented rationale, source or review.</li><li><strong>Inconsistent definitions.</strong> Suppliers use different boundaries, units and reporting periods, so data cannot be aggregated.</li><li><strong>Weak evidence.</strong> Supplier responses arrive as unsigned spreadsheets with no supporting invoices, meter readings or HR records.</li><li><strong>MSME capacity.</strong> Small suppliers lack systems and expertise, and a request for dozens of data points yields low response rates.</li><li><strong>Ownership gaps.</strong> Sustainability, procurement, finance and IT each hold part of the data, and none is accountable for the whole.</li></ul><h2>5. A Readiness Roadmap</h2><h2>Step 1: Define Scope and Materiality</h2><p>Build the supplier and distributor universe from purchase and sales ledgers. Rank partners by value, then identify those required to reach the 75% threshold. Overlay risk factors such as sector, geography and prior incidents to decide where deeper engagement is warranted.</p><h2>Step 2: Standardise Methodology</h2><p>Document definitions, boundaries and calculation methods for each indicator. For emissions, align with the GHG Protocol Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Standard, specify which of the 15 categories are relevant, and record the emission factors and their sources. Maintain a methodology manual that an assurance provider can read and test.</p><h2>Step 3: Design a Supplier Data Collection Process</h2><p>Use a short, standard template focused on the BRSR Core indicators rather than a long questionnaire. Provide guidance notes, training sessions and clear deadlines. Request a management sign-off on each submission, and for key suppliers, supporting evidence such as utility bills, safety logs and payroll summaries.</p><h2>Step 4: Build Controls and an Audit Trail</h2><p>Treat sustainability data like financial data. Assign data owners, implement maker-checker reviews, reconcile totals to source systems, retain version history and document every estimate or extrapolation. A central repository with access controls is far easier to assure than scattered files.</p><h2>Step 5: Apply Data Quality Tiers</h2><p>Classify each data point as measured, calculated from primary activity data, or estimated from secondary data. Disclose the proportion in each tier and set a target to improve it each year. Transparent estimation is more defensible than false precision.</p><h2>Step 6: Run a Pre-Assurance Dry Run</h2><p>Before the formal engagement, conduct an internal or independent readiness review. Select a sample of suppliers, trace reported figures back to source evidence and log exceptions. Fix control weaknesses while there is still time to do so.</p><h2>Step 7: Embed Governance and Supplier Incentives</h2><p>Report progress to the Audit or ESG Committee. Include data submission and quality expectations in supplier codes of conduct and contracts, and consider preferred-supplier benefits or capacity-building support for MSMEs rather than relying on penalties alone.</p><h2>6. Technology and Capability</h2><p>Spreadsheets break down at scale. Consider supplier portals, ERP integration and ESG data platforms that offer workflow, validation rules, and audit logs. Technology cannot replace clear definitions and ownership, but it reduces manual error and makes evidence retrieval faster during assurance fieldwork.</p><h2>7. Preparing for Reasonable Assurance</h2><p>Reasonable assurance requires a deeper evaluation of controls and more extensive substantive testing than limited assurance. Companies that begin building control environments now, particularly around GHG, energy and workforce data, will find the transition far less disruptive. Early voluntary reasonable assurance on selected KPIs also signals confidence to investors.</p><h2>Frequently Asked Questions</h2><h2>Who must provide value chain disclosures?</h2><p>The top 250 listed entities are in scope from FY 2025-26, covering suppliers and distributors that account for 75% of purchases and sales by value.</p><h2>Is value chain data assured?</h2><p>It is initially subject to limited, comfort-level assurance. Companies should still expect external scrutiny of the data.</p><h2>Which standards should we align to?</h2><p>The GHG Protocol Scope 3 Standard for emissions, ISAE 3000 (Revised) or SAE 3000 for assurance engagements, ISO 14064-3 for GHG verification, and ISSA 5000 as the emerging global benchmark.</p><h2>Conclusion and Next Steps</h2><p>Value chain data is where ESG credibility will be won or lost. Companies that map their supplier universe, standardise methods, build controls and rehearse assurance will turn a compliance burden into a competitive advantage. Start this quarter: define your 75% supplier universe, appoint a single accountable owner, and commission a readiness assessment before your next reporting cycle.</p><p><em>Regulatory note: The timelines and thresholds above reflect SEBI requirements as understood at the time of writing. Readers should consult current SEBI circulars when finalising reporting plans.</em></p>

Actionable Recommendations

Map suppliers and distributors covering 75% of purchases and sales by value.

Appoint a single accountable owner for value chain ESG data.

Document methodologies aligned to the GHG Protocol Scope 3 Standard.

Introduce a standard supplier template with management sign-off and evidence requests.

Run a pre-assurance dry run on a sample of suppliers.

Build capacity-support programmes for MSME suppliers.

Plan voluntarily for reasonable assurance on key BRSR Core indicators.

Dr. Sandeep Chalke

Dr. Sandeep Chalke, PhD

Founder & Principal Consultant at Praxis Consulting with 30+ years of expertise in GRC, Enterprise Risk Management, and International Management Standards. A published author of Mastering ISO 17025, School Safety Blueprint, and ISO 19011:2026 — Auditing Excellence, he has trained over 5,000 professionals worldwide.

Transform Insights into Action

Partner with Praxis Consulting to implement these strategies in your organization.

Schedule a Consultation